A recent case in the office brought up an interesting question about the effect of information appearing in the recitals at the beginning of a contract but nowhere else in the contract. Opposing counsel based its case on the argument that because one of the “whereas” clauses of a loan agreement said that the borrower contemplated using the proceeds of the loan for a particular purpose, the alleged failure to use the proceeds for thatpurpose constituted a breach of the agreement - even though the paragraphs of the agreement defining “events of default” made no mention of how the loan proceeds were to be used.

    Research on this point revealed that a term appearing in a recital but nowhere else is not part of the contract. Burr v. American Spiral Spring Butt Co., 36 Sickels 175, 81 N.Y. 175(1880)(affirming order granting judgment for plaintiff publisher in anaction to recover from defendants for price of advertisement inplaintiff’s book: plaintiff’s failure to prove that it conducted sales in the manner described in a recital clause, but not appearing anywhere else in the contract, did not preclude recovery by plaintiff); see also  Jones Apparel Group, Inc. v. Polo Ralph Lauren Corp., 16 A.D.3d 279, 791 N.Y.S.2d 409 (1st Dept 2005)(recitals in contract are not part of operative agreement); Trump Village Section 3, Inc. v. New York State Housing Finance Agency, 292 A.D.2d 156, 739 N.Y.S.2d 37 (1st Dept 2002)(recital clause of contract did not impose contractual obligations beyond those specifically set forth in the contract); Ross v. Ross, 233 A.D. 626, 635, 253 N.Y.S. 871, 882 (1st Dept 1931)(“recitals in a contract form no part thereof, and at most indicate but the purposes and motives of the parties”).
                          

News

Business

[09/08] PriceSmart's revenue increase in August

[09/08] Oracle plans to give Hurd $950,0000 annual salary

[09/08] India court upholds big tax bill against Vodafone

[09/08] German exports slightly lower on month in July

[09/08] All eyes on BP report on Gulf oil spill disaster

[09/08] BP shares gain after Gulf report

[09/08] Smithfield posts 1Q profit on higher pork prices

[09/08] China's Hu calls for stable ties with US

[09/08] China blacks out towns to meet energy goal

[09/08] Swisscom to delist troubled Italian unit Fastweb

[09/08] BP shares move higher ahead of Gulf report

[09/08] BP report blames itself, others for oil spill

[09/08] Abstinent Mormon farmers grow barley for beer

[09/08] BP: Multiple companies, teams contributed to spill

[09/08] Talbots returns to 2Q profit, offers weak outlook

[09/08] Dollar sinks to 15-year low against Japanese yen

[09/08] ADWATCH: Ads attacking health plan miss some facts

[09/08] AP Exclusive: Back to work after salmonella case

[09/08] Smithfield reports 1st-quarter profit

[09/08] Oil falls below $74 on EU bank debt worries

Back to Main

Web Resources

skolnik@cpsslaw.comFindLaw
Thomson West
U.S. Courts
Westlaw
United States Chamber of Commerce
FirstGov
Legislative Branch
Library of Congress
White House
Internal Revenue Service
National Weather Service
Yahoo!Maps
YellowPages.com
New York Times
Newspapers Online
USA Today
Wall Street Journal
AOL
Google
Yahoo!Legal Blog Directory